SCARR’S PIZZA: A Slice of New York Heaven with Authentic Flavors

If you’re a true pizza lover and find yourself in New York City, Scarr’s Pizza is an absolute must-visit. ✨

This cult-favorite pizzeria recently moved to its new location at 35 Orchard Street, just across from its original slice shop. Let us tell you, the buzz around this place is real, and after experiencing it firsthand, we can understand why people line up down the block.

To learn more about this restaurant, check out review below. 🍲

. . .

Upon entering the new Scarr’s Pizza, you can feel the vibrant energy and smell the irresistible aroma of freshly baked pizza. The space is bigger than its humble beginnings, but it still maintains the charm that made it so beloved. The modern dining room adds a touch of contemporary flair while staying true to its roots.

Owned by the talented Scarr Pimentel, one of the few Black pizza makers in the city, Scarr’s Pizza has become synonymous with the perfect New York slice. The New York Times even recognized it as one of the top 100 restaurants in the city, and for a good reason. The attention to detail and the dedication to using all-natural and organic ingredients sets Scarr’s apart from the rest.

The menu at Scarr’s Pizza is a testament to their commitment to quality. Their pizza dough is made with 100% stone-milled flour, resulting in a crust that strikes the perfect balance between lightness and chewiness. Whether you’re a fan of classic Margherita, a lover of white pies, or seeking vegan options, they have something to satisfy every palate.

But what truly sets Scarr’s Pizza apart is the passion and expertise that goes into each slice. Scarr Pimentel’s journey, starting from his days at iconic establishments like Lombardi’s and Emilio’s Ballato, has shaped his culinary prowess. His dedication to perfecting the art of pizza-making is evident in every bite.

As a bonus, Scarr’s Pizza has collaborated with renowned brands like Timberland and film company A24, showcasing their influence beyond the world of pizza. You can even get your hands on some signature merchandise, adding a stylish touch to your pizza experience.

Scarr’s Pizza is not just a place to enjoy phenomenal pizza—it’s an experience that celebrates the rich heritage and craftsmanship behind this beloved culinary delight. So, if you’re ready to embark on a pizza adventure like no other, head over to 35 Orchard Street and let Scarr’s Pizza work its magic. ✨

Menu highlights

If you’re wondering what delectable treats await you at Scarr’s Pizza, let us give you a sneak peek into some of their mouthwatering menu highlights:

• Vegan Caesar Salad: A refreshing salad made with cashew-based dressing. It can be customized with breaded chicken or anchovies. Price: $8/15.
• Side of Eggplant Parm: Tender eggplant slices topped with marinara sauce and melted cheese. Price: $6.
• Side of Chicken Parm: Juicy chicken cutlets smothered in tomato sauce and melted cheese. Price: $7.
• Side of Meatball Parm: Flavorful meatballs served with marinara sauce and melted cheese. Price: $8.
• Vegan Garlic Knots: Delicious garlic-infused knots that are vegan-friendly. Price: $5.
• Add Fresh Mozzarella: Creamy and melty fresh mozzarella that can be added to any pizza. Price: $4.
• Classic Pepperoni Pizza: A timeless favorite topped with pepperoni. Price: $18/24 (Small/Large).
• Sicilian Pizza: Authentic Sicilian-style pizza. Price: $26 (Large).
• Grandma Pizza: A delicious twist with fresh garlic and basil. Price: $24 (Large).
• Hotboi Pizza: A spicy delight featuring beef pepperoni, jalapenos, and extra hot honey. Price: $20/28 (Small/Large).
• Vegan Pizza: A plant-based option with vegan cheese and basil. Price: $22/30 (Small/Large).
  
  These are just a few highlights from Scarr’s Pizza’s extensive menu. Whether you’re a fan of classic pepperoni, Sicilian-style pizza, or looking for vegan options, Scarr’s has something for everyone. Their commitment to using all-natural and organic ingredients shines through in every bite. ✨

Final thoughts

Scarr’s Pizza in NYC is more than just a place to grab a slice—it’s a testament to the artistry and passion that goes into creating the perfect pie. From its humble beginnings in 2016 to its recent relocation on Orchard Street, Scarr’s has remained a beloved culinary destination for pizza aficionados and curious foodies alike.

What sets Scarr’s Pizza apart is its commitment to both tradition and innovation. While they honor the timeless techniques of New York-style pizza making, they also embrace new flavors and ingredients to push the boundaries of what a slice can be. The use of all-natural and organic ingredients elevates each bite, ensuring a harmonious blend of flavors that will leave you craving more.

So, whether you’re a lifelong New Yorker or a curious traveler, make sure to add Scarr’s Pizza to your culinary bucket list. It’s a place where the past meets the present, where the familiar meets the unexpected. Prepare yourself for a pizza experience that will ignite your taste buds and leave you with a newfound appreciation for this timeless dish.

Directions

Finding your way to Scarr’s Pizza is quite simple. The new location is situated at 35 Orchard Street, on the Chinatown/LES border. If you’re already familiar with the area, you’ll have no trouble spotting it.

Address: 35 Orchard Street, New York
Phone: (212) 334-3481
Website: www.scarrspizza.com
Reservations: Book your table through their website

To make the most of your visit, we recommend planning ahead and making a reservation through their website or by calling (212) 334-3481. The new Scarr’s Pizza operates from 12 PM to 12 AM on Fridays and Saturdays, and from 12 PM to 11 PM on Sundays through Thursdays.

If you’re traveling by public transport, you can take the subway and get off at the nearest stations, such as East Broadway (F train) or Delancey Street-Essex Street (J/M/Z trains). From there, it’s just a short walk to Scarr’s Pizza.

For those driving, be prepared for the hustle and bustle of New York City streets. Street parking may be limited, so it’s advisable to use a rideshare service or public transport to reach the pizzeria.

No matter how you choose to get there, the journey to Scarr’s Pizza is undoubtedly worth it. So grab your appetite and head over to experience their legendary New York slices for yourself!

Note: Prices and menu items may be subject to change, so it’s always a good idea to check with Scarr’s Pizza for the most up-to-date information.

Enjoy your pizza adventure at Scarr’s Pizza NYC!✨

. . .

Thank you for reading our restaurant review for SCARR’S PIZZA!
For more, make sure to subscribe to our newsletter! ✨